NewsMarketing

EU court adviser says Facebook can’t call itself free if users pay in data

For Advocate General Laila Medina, handing over data and accepting its commercial use counts as payment. The EU's top court still has to rule.

Advertisement

An adviser to the European Union’s highest court says a service is not “free” if users must hand over personal data and accept its commercial use to sign up. Advocate General Laila Medina delivered that opinion on November 19, 2026, in Case C-643/25, about a 2015 Facebook slogan. If the judges agree, other services that require personal data for commercial use could see their “free” label challenged.

Advocates general are independent advisers at the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU). They propose how the judges should decide a case before they deliberate. Her opinion does not bind the judges. Their ruling will bind the German court that sent the case and other national courts facing a similar question.

How a 2015 slogan reached the CJEU

In February 2015, Facebook’s German-language registration page read “Facebook ist und bleibt kostenlos.” The Court’s press release translates it as “Facebook is and remains free.” According to the French tech news site Next, Facebook displayed the slogan until 2019. The French version read « C’est gratuit (et ça le restera toujours) », or “It’s free (and always will be).”

Advertisement

The Federation of German Consumer Organisations (vzbv) took the slogan to court. It argued that users pay for Facebook with their data. It asked for an order barring Meta Platforms Ireland, the Meta company that operates Facebook in the EU, from using the slogan with consumers living in Germany.

The Regional Court of Berlin, the trial court, dismissed the case on January 16, 2018. In its view, the ban on calling a product free covers only hidden costs: an obligation to pay or a financial burden. Handing over data, it said, affects only the consumer’s non-financial interests. The Higher Regional Court of Berlin, the appeals court, upheld that decision on December 20, 2019.

The vzbv then took the case to the Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof), Germany’s highest court for civil and criminal cases. After a hearing on July 3, 2025, that court paused the case and sent a single question to the CJEU. The EU’s Unfair Commercial Practices Directive refers to a “cost.” Does that word cover handing over personal data and consenting to its commercial use?

An EU blacklist covers the word “free”

Annex I of that directive, formally Directive 2005/29 of May 11, 2005, is a blacklist of business practices banned in all circumstances. For those practices, the advocate general notes, there is no case-by-case assessment. Nobody has to show that the average consumer was actually misled.

Advertisement

Point 20 of that annex bans “describing a product as ‘gratis’, ‘free’, ‘without charge’ or similar if the consumer has to pay anything other than the unavoidable cost” of responding to the offer and of delivery. In France, the ban appears in the Consumer Code, as item 19 of Article L121-4, among the practices deemed misleading.

Her answer: data counts as payment

The advocate general’s answer to the German court is yes. In her opinion, what the consumer “has to pay” includes disclosing personal data and consenting to its use for commercial purposes. There is one exception: data processed only to supply the service or to let the company meet its legal obligations.

She first notes that the directive’s wording differs by language. The Spanish and Polish versions point to a sum of money. The German version covers a burden of any kind. Since the wording alone does not settle it, she looks at the context and purpose of the rule.

She also cites Peek & Cloppenburg, a 2021 Court ruling about an advertorial, an ad dressed up as an article. The advertiser had only let the media outlet use some images free of charge. The Court held that the advertiser could still have “paid” for the advertorial, provided that benefit had economic value and a definite link to its publication. Paying, she notes, did not require the advertiser to give anything up: it kept its images, just as users keep their data.

Advertisement

To show that the data has value, she relies on a July 4, 2023, Court ruling in another Meta case. That ruling described Facebook’s business model, funded by targeted advertising built on detailed user profiles. She concludes that the data and consent given at sign-up have value for the operator and fund the service. The definite link is there too, in her view, because users cannot sign up without providing them.

Other EU laws already treat data as consideration

Other EU laws already cover digital services obtained in exchange for data instead of money, she points out. They include the 2019 directive on contracts for digital content and services and the 2011 Consumer Rights Directive, as amended. The Court’s press release sums up her reasoning: “It would be inconsistent to regard such arrangements as involving consideration under those rules while allowing the same services to be presented as free under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive.” In legal terms, “consideration” means what is given in exchange.

She adds a consumer protection argument. Someone who pays in euros knows the price. Someone who provides data often does not know what it is worth or how widely it is used for advertising. Limiting the ban to money, she argues, would rob it of much of its force in online services, where offers billed as free are most common.

She rejects Meta’s three objections

Meta raised three objections. The first was that the blacklist is a closed list that only EU lawmakers can change. She replies that this does not mean the words describing each listed practice must be read narrowly.

Advertisement

The second was that the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), the EU’s personal data law, already protects users. She answers that the two laws apply side by side. The GDPR governs how data is processed, while the directive governs whether commercial claims are accurate. Calling a service free is not, in itself, a form of processing personal data.

The third rested on the freedom to conduct a business and the freedom to provide services across the EU. According to the press release, companies remain free to offer services in exchange for personal data, “but cannot describe them as ‘free’ where such consideration is required.”

Regulators already challenged Meta’s “free” claim in 2024

In a separate proceeding, European consumer authorities led by France’s consumer protection agency, the DGCCRF, had already targeted the word “free.” On July 22, 2024, the Consumer Protection Cooperation (CPC) Network, which links national consumer authorities, wrote to Meta about its “pay or consent” model. Introduced in the EU in November 2023, the model asks users to choose between a paid ad-free subscription and letting their data be used for targeted ads.

The European Commission, the EU’s executive arm, coordinated the action. According to its press release, one concern was that Meta misled consumers by using the word “free” while requiring users who do not pay to accept that their data will be used for advertising. Meta had until September 1, 2024, to respond.

The same model led to another case. On March 25, 2024, the Commission opened proceedings against Meta under the Digital Markets Act (DMA), which sets obligations for the largest platforms. That case led on April 23, 2025, to a 200 million euro fine. Meta also faces other actions in Europe over its use of data, such as the 805 million euro fine imposed in Italy on November 14, 2026 by the Italian data protection authority.

The limits of the opinion

CJEU judges do not have to follow the opinion. They will answer only the German court’s question, and their ruling will come later.

The opinion also leaves questions open, according to PPC Land, a digital advertising news site. It does not say whether data collected without any action by the user, such as cookies or IP addresses, is enough to count as payment. Nor does it address the ad-free subscription or the less personalized ads option that Meta offers in the EU.

Advertisement

What it means

The opinion proposes a new test for “free.” The Berlin trial and appeals courts held that a service was free as long as users paid no money. The advocate general looks instead at what the required data is used for. If the data is used for anything beyond supplying the service or meeting legal duties, such as funding targeted ads, the word “free” falls under the blacklist.

The reasoning reaches beyond Facebook. According to the opinion, online services billed as free are often funded by collecting data. In its 2021 guidance on the directive, the Commission already noted that many of them collect users’ identity and email address.

If the Court follows its advocate general, the “free” label could be challenged for any service that requires users to hand over personal data and consent to its commercial use. A challenger would not have to prove that any consumer was misled.

Trading a service for data remains legal: the opinion targets only how the deal is presented. Open questions include how far the exception for data needed to run the service extends and how Meta has responded to the CPC Network since 2024. EU consumer rules are also changing, with the Digital Fairness Act proposal the Commission presented on November 11, 2026.

The next step is the CJEU ruling. No date has been announced. Germany’s Federal Court of Justice will then decide whether the 2015 slogan was unlawful.

Sources

Advertisement

Leave a Comment